2
0

Adjust mpw-bench to compare to hmac-sha-256 instead of sha-256, their performance characteristics are quite different.

This commit is contained in:
Maarten Billemont 2016-08-24 00:07:58 -04:00
parent d560a2052d
commit eea9051dbb

View File

@ -59,32 +59,33 @@ int main(int argc, char *const argv[]) {
// Start MPW // Start MPW
unsigned int iterations = 100; unsigned int iterations = 100;
const uint8_t *masterKey = NULL;
mpw_getTime( &startTime ); mpw_getTime( &startTime );
for (int i = 0; i < iterations; ++i) { for (int i = 0; i < iterations; ++i) {
const uint8_t *masterKey = mpw_masterKeyForUser( free( (void *)masterKey );
fullName, masterPassword, MPAlgorithmVersionCurrent ); masterKey = mpw_masterKeyForUser( fullName, masterPassword, MPAlgorithmVersionCurrent );
if (!masterKey) if (!masterKey)
ftl( "Could not allocate master key: %d\n", errno ); ftl( "Could not allocate master key: %d\n", errno );
free( (void *)mpw_passwordForSite( free( (void *)mpw_passwordForSite(
masterKey, siteName, siteType, siteCounter, siteVariant, siteContext, MPAlgorithmVersionCurrent ) ); masterKey, siteName, siteType, siteCounter, siteVariant, siteContext, MPAlgorithmVersionCurrent ) );
free( (void *)masterKey );
if (i % ( iterations / 100 ) == 0) if (i % ( iterations / 100 ) == 0)
fprintf( stderr, "\rmpw: iteration %d / %d (%d%%)..", i, iterations, i * 100 / iterations ); fprintf( stderr, "\rmpw: iteration %d / %d (%u%%)..", i, iterations, i * 100 / iterations );
} }
const double mpwSpeed = mpw_showSpeed( startTime, iterations, "mpw" ); const double mpwSpeed = mpw_showSpeed( startTime, iterations, "mpw" );
// Start SHA-256 // Start HMAC-SHA-256
iterations = 45000000; uint8_t *sitePasswordInfo = malloc( 128 );
iterations = 5500000;
uint8_t hash[32]; uint8_t hash[32];
mpw_getTime( &startTime ); mpw_getTime( &startTime );
for (int i = 0; i < iterations; ++i) { for (int i = 0; i < iterations; ++i) {
SHA256_Buf( masterPassword, strlen( masterPassword ), hash ); free( (void *)mpw_hmac_sha256( masterKey, MP_dkLen, sitePasswordInfo, 128 ) );
if (i % ( iterations / 100 ) == 0) if (i % ( iterations / 100 ) == 0)
fprintf( stderr, "\rsha256: iteration %d / %d (%d%%)..", i, iterations, i * 100 / iterations ); fprintf( stderr, "\rhmac-sha-256: iteration %d / %d (%u%%)..", i, iterations, i * 100 / iterations );
} }
const double sha256Speed = mpw_showSpeed( startTime, iterations, "sha256" ); const double hmacSha256Speed = mpw_showSpeed( startTime, iterations, "hmac-sha-256" );
// Start BCrypt // Start BCrypt
int bcrypt_cost = 9; int bcrypt_cost = 9;
@ -94,13 +95,13 @@ int main(int argc, char *const argv[]) {
crypt( masterPassword, crypt_gensalt( "$2b$", bcrypt_cost, fullName, strlen( fullName ) ) ); crypt( masterPassword, crypt_gensalt( "$2b$", bcrypt_cost, fullName, strlen( fullName ) ) );
if (i % ( iterations / 100 ) == 0) if (i % ( iterations / 100 ) == 0)
fprintf( stderr, "\rbcrypt (cost %d): iteration %d / %d (%d%%)..", bcrypt_cost, i, iterations, i * 100 / iterations ); fprintf( stderr, "\rbcrypt (cost %d): iteration %d / %d (%u%%)..", bcrypt_cost, i, iterations, i * 100 / iterations );
} }
const double bcrypt9Speed = mpw_showSpeed( startTime, iterations, "bcrypt9" ); const double bcrypt9Speed = mpw_showSpeed( startTime, iterations, "bcrypt9" );
// Summarize. // Summarize.
fprintf( stdout, "\n== SUMMARY ==\nOn this machine,\n" ); fprintf( stdout, "\n== SUMMARY ==\nOn this machine,\n" );
fprintf( stdout, " - mpw is %f times slower than sha256 (reference: 320000 on an MBP Late 2013).\n", sha256Speed / mpwSpeed ); fprintf( stdout, " - mpw is %f times slower than hmac-sha-256 (reference: 320000 on an MBP Late 2013).\n", hmacSha256Speed / mpwSpeed );
fprintf( stdout, " - mpw is %f times slower than bcrypt (cost 9) (reference: 22 on an MBP Late 2013).\n", bcrypt9Speed / mpwSpeed ); fprintf( stdout, " - mpw is %f times slower than bcrypt (cost 9) (reference: 22 on an MBP Late 2013).\n", bcrypt9Speed / mpwSpeed );
return 0; return 0;